Is your dig job running over? Track yards hauled against yards bid
How to count loads on site, turn them into yards, check them against the bid every day, and what to do the day you see you are running over.
You find out a dig job ran over when the invoice or the final trucking bill shows up, and by then the dirt is gone and the conversation with the customer is a fight. The fix is boring: count every load that leaves, turn the count into yards, and compare it to the yards you bid at the end of every day. Ten minutes a day tells you on day two what the invoice would tell you on day twenty.
Count the loads where they happen
The count has to come from the gate or the cut, not from memory at the end of the week. Three sources, in order of how much you can trust them:
- Scale tickets. The dump or the plant weighs the truck and prints a ticket. Best number you will get, but it is in tons, not yards, so you need a weight per yard to use it. Keep tons as tons and do not guess a conversion you cannot defend.
- Truck tickets. The trucker hands a slip per load, often with the truck number and the date. Ask for them every load and collect them daily. A missing ticket is a missing bill later.
- A tally at the site. One person, one clipboard or phone, one mark per truck leaving. Rough, but it is the check on the other two. If the tally says 38 loads and you hold 34 tickets, someone is going to bill you for four loads you cannot match.
Photograph each ticket the same day. A slip in a truck door pocket is gone by Friday.
Bank yards, loose yards, and which one you are counting
Your bid is almost always in bank yards, measured in the ground. The truck carries loose yards, because dug soil fluffs up. Hauling is paid on what is in the truck. If you count loads and compare them straight to bank yards, you will think you are way over when you are not, or the reverse.
Our bank vs loose yards page puts typical soil swell at 20 to 30 percent, with rock higher. TrackOver's trench calculator starts at 25 percent swell, and says plainly that this is a default only: your soil, moisture and how it was dug change it. Use your own number if you have one from a past job. Set swell to 0 in that calculator to see bank yards, and use the dirt calculator to size a pad or a hole.
A worked example, with made-up numbers and the 25 percent default so you can follow the arithmetic:
- You bid 400 bank yards of cut.
- At 25 percent swell that is 400 x 1.25 = 500 loose yards of trucking.
- With 16 yard trucks (the starting truck size in TrackOver's bid builder, and only an example; use what your trucks carry), 500 / 16 = 31.25, so about 32 loads.
- If you are at 40 loads after day three and the hole is not done, you are already over, and you know it before the dump bills come in.
Our post on how many yards fit in a dump truck covers the truck side. Pick one yardage and write it on the sheet: "bank" or "loose". Convert once, in writing.
Check the bid every day
At the end of each day, write down three numbers:
- Loads out today, and total so far.
- Total yards out, in the same yardage as the bid. Loads times truck size, then back to bank if the bid is bank.
- What is left to dig. Look at the hole, not the plan.
Then compare: yards out plus yards left should equal the bid. If it is more, you are running over. The earlier in the job you see it, the more options you have: a different haul route, fuller trucks, a different dump, a talk with the customer while the work is still in front of you.
Also watch the pace, not just the total. If the bid assumed a number of yards an hour and your crew is moving less, you will burn the hours budget even if the total yards come out right. Truck count, haul distance and where the excavator is waiting are the usual reasons.
When you are running over
Call the customer early, with numbers. "We bid 400 yards and we are at 340 with a third of the hole left. Here are the tickets" is a conversation. "The dirt came out to more than we thought" at invoice time is a dispute.
Then separate the reasons:
- Conditions changed. Wet soil, rock, unsuitable material, an old foundation. If your estimate had a rock and unsuitable soil clause, this is the change that clause was written for.
- The customer added work. A bigger pad, an extra trench, a second pile to haul off.
- Your bid was light. This is the one you eat, and the one you learn from. Write the real number down for the next estimate.
For the first two, write a change order before you keep hauling: what changed, how many extra yards or loads, the price per unit, and a signature. Attach the tickets. Work done on a handshake is the work that does not get paid.
How TrackOver does it
If the job was made from a DirtOps bid, the crew logs each load as a haul ticket from the phone, with a photo of the paper ticket. Then two office screens do the comparing for you:
- Daily production shows yards hauled by day, with loads, crew hours, machine hours and cost per yard. A ticket in yards counts as yards. A ticket in loads counts as the yards per load you set on that screen. Tons stay tons. Dirt moved on site without a truck is not on a ticket, so it is not counted. When the job came from a DirtOps bid, a card sets the yards the bid's production rate says the crew should have moved in the hours worked next to the yards actually hauled, and shows the percent. If the pace falls under 85 percent of the bid, it shows a warning to look at truck count, haul distance or the rate.
- Bid vs actual lists each bid line with the quantity you bid, what was logged, what the loads add, and how far over or under you are. A line counts as over once it passes the bid by more than half a percent, and the screen counts the lines that are over and tells you to talk to the customer about a change order. When you bill quantities, anything past the bid is flagged and is not billed on that invoice: it is left for a change order.
Two honest limits. It only compares against a bid when the job came from a DirtOps bid with a signed estimate, and it only counts what the crew actually logs. If tickets are not entered, the numbers will look fine when they are not. The screens are in the DirtOps part of TrackOver, so check pricing for what your plan includes.
Common questions
Should I count loads or yards? Count loads at the gate, then turn them into yards with the truck size you actually use. Loads are easy to count and hard to argue with; yards are what the bid is written in.
Do I compare bank yards or loose yards to the bid? The same kind as the bid. Most dig bids are in bank yards, so convert the loose yards in the trucks back to bank with your swell number.
What swell number should I use? Your own, from past jobs on similar soil. If you have none, 20 to 30 percent is the usual range for soil, and rock runs higher. Treat it as a starting point.
When do I call the customer? As soon as the daily check says you will pass the bid, not when the hole is finished.
If you want yards hauled sitting next to yards bid without building a spreadsheet, TrackOver for excavation keeps the tickets, the bid and the change orders on the same job. Start the 7-day free trial and run one dig through it.