What is an EMR? The experience mod, explained for dirt contractors
What an EMR is, how the workers' comp experience mod is calculated in general terms, why GCs ask for it, and what an excavation company can do about it.
An EMR is your experience mod: a number that adjusts your workers' comp premium based on your own claims history, where 1.00 is the baseline, below 1.00 is better than expected, and above 1.00 means you pay more. A high mod can keep you off a GC's bid list, so learn how it is figured before a prequalification form asks for it.
Sooner or later a prequalification form asks for your EMR, and for a lot of small contractors that is the first time they have heard the term. Then a GC says yours is too high to work on their jobs, and it becomes one of the most important numbers in the company.
Here is what the experience modification rate is, how it gets figured in general terms, and what you can actually do about it. The rules vary by state and change over time, so treat this as a starting point and ask your insurance agent about the specifics where you work.
What is an EMR?
An EMR, also called an experience mod or a mod rate, is a number that adjusts your workers' comp premium based on your own claims history. It compares the losses your company actually had to the losses expected for a company of your size doing your kind of work, based on your payroll and your class codes.
- 1.00 is the baseline. Your claims history is about what would be expected.
- Under 1.00 means better than expected, and your premium is adjusted down.
- Over 1.00 means worse than expected, and your premium is adjusted up.
The mod is applied to your premium, so a company over 1.00 pays more than a similar company with a better record, for the same payroll and the same class codes.
Not every company has a mod. Smaller companies may fall below the size where experience rating kicks in. If a form asks for your EMR and you are not rated, ask your agent how to answer, and say so on the form rather than guessing.
Who calculates it, and from what?
In most states the mod is calculated by NCCI, the National Council on Compensation Insurance. Some states run their own rating bureau instead. Your carrier does not just pick the number. The bureau calculates it from the payroll and claims data your carriers report.
The calculation generally uses about three years of payroll and claims, and it usually leaves out the most recent policy year, because those claims are too new to have settled numbers. That means the mod you carry this year reflects claims from a few years back. A claim that happens today may not show up in your mod for a while, and once it does, it tends to stay for about three years before it rolls off.
Why a lot of small claims can hurt more than one big one
This surprises people. The formula treats how often claims happen as a better predictor of future losses than how big any one claim is. In general terms, the first part of each claim counts fully, and the part of a large claim above that counts for much less. So a company with many small injuries can end up with a worse mod than a company with one serious one, even when the total dollars are similar.
The lesson is not that big injuries do not matter. It is that the steady trickle of cuts, strains, and eye injuries that everyone shrugs off is exactly what pushes the number up. How claims are split and weighted varies by state and gets adjusted over time, so your agent is the one to walk you through your own worksheet.
Why GCs and owners ask for it
A GC hiring an excavation sub cannot see your safety culture from their office. The EMR is a number they can see. It is imperfect and it lags, but it is standardized, and it says something about whether people get hurt on your jobs.
Many GCs and owners set a maximum and will not hire subs above it, or will want an explanation and a safety plan before they do. Our piece on getting on a GC's bid list covers the rest of what a prequalification packet asks for. Because the mod also feeds straight into your premium, a high one costs you twice: once in what you pay for insurance, and again in work you do not get to bid.
What can you actually influence?
You cannot change the past three years. You can change what goes into the next three.
- Prevent the injuries. It sounds obvious, but it is the whole game. Trenches, swing radius, and trucks backing up are where serious dirt injuries come from. Regular toolbox talks keep those in front of the crew, and our article on trench safety covers protective systems.
- Get people back to work. A return-to-work program that offers modified or light duty, when the doctor allows it, can keep a claim smaller than it would be if the person sat at home. Ask your carrier how to set one up properly.
- Report claims promptly. Tell your carrier about an injury right away. Late reporting tends to make claims harder to manage and more expensive, and that cost can end up in your mod.
- Know where care is. Make sure foremen know where to take an injured worker from each job, and what to do first.
- Keep class codes right. Payroll reported under the wrong class codes changes the expected losses in the formula. Make sure your payroll reporting reflects the work people actually do.
- Check your worksheet. Ask your agent for the rating worksheet every year and read it. Look for claims that are not yours, claims that closed for less than the amount still shown, payroll that looks wrong, and injuries caused by someone else that the carrier may be able to recover from them. Errors happen, and your agent can ask for a correction.
Explaining a high mod
If your mod is over 1.00, do not hide it. The GC will find out anyway. Explain it briefly on the prequalification form instead:
- What happened, in a sentence or two
- What you changed afterward: training, equipment, a new foreman, a written program
- Your record since then
- When the claim years roll out of the calculation, if your agent can tell you
An honest explanation with a real plan behind it reads a lot better than a blank box, and some GCs will work with you on that basis while the number comes down.
Questions to ask your agent
- Are we experience rated, and which bureau calculates our mod?
- Can I see this year's worksheet, and last year's?
- Which claims are driving our number, and when do they roll off?
- Are our class codes and payroll reported correctly?
- Do we have a return-to-work program the carrier supports?
- Does anything on the worksheet look wrong to you?
TrackOver's safety tools let a foreman run toolbox talks from the phone and log them with the date, job, and attendance, and incidents can be documented with photos and witnesses while they are fresh. That is the paper trail a GC or a carrier asks about. If that would help, try TrackOver free.
Common questions
What is a good EMR for a construction company? A mod at or under 1.00 means your claims history is at or better than expected for your size and type of work. Many GCs and owners set their own maximum, so ask the ones you want to work for what theirs is.
How is an EMR calculated? A rating bureau, NCCI in most states and a state bureau in some others, compares your actual workers' comp losses to the losses expected for your payroll and class codes. It generally uses about three years of data and leaves out the most recent policy year. Ask your agent how it works in your state.
How long does a claim affect my EMR? Generally about three years, since the calculation uses roughly three years of history and leaves out the most recent year. The timing depends on your policy dates and your state, so ask your agent when a specific claim rolls off.
Can I lower my EMR quickly? Not really, because it is built from past years. What you can do right away is check your worksheet for errors, report claims promptly and manage them with return to work, and prevent new injuries so future years come in better.